Note: Musings from the Oil Patch reflects an eclectic collection of stories and analyses dealing with issues and developments within the energy industry that I feel have potentially significant implications for executives operating oilfield service companies. The newsletter currently anticipates a semi-monthly publishing schedule, but periodically the event and news flow may dictate a more frequent schedule. As always, I welcome your comments and observations. Allen Brooks
Russian Oil Production Outlook Reduced
In its latest quarterly report, the Ministry of Economic Development and Trade has lowered its forecast for Russian oil production. The new forecast calls for Russian oil production to grow by only 2.4% to 9.42 million barrels per day (b/d). That forecast is 300,000 b/d below other official Russian projections that call for the country’s oil production to grow by as much as 5%.
The cutback in production growth is due to the anticipated, and emerging, impact on
The high end of the Ministry’s new forecast range, 9.66 million b/d, is below the 9.72 million b/d forecast issued last month by the Federal Energy Agency. That forecast called for an almost 6% gain in production in 2005, much more in line with the previous five year growth rate in Russian oil production of 8%. During those years,
The International Energy Agency (IEA) recently revised its forecast for Russian oil production, reducing the grow rate to 3.6%, or 9.6 million b/d, in line with their estimate for first quarter 2005 production. Interestingly, the April monthly oil report issued by OPEC pointed out that Russian oil production had fallen 80,000 b/d below its projection. As a result of this shortfall, OPEC revised downward its forecast for Russian oil production growth in 2005. OPEC is now forecasting a 360,000 b/d increase versus its prior (March) forecast for growth of 450,000 b/d.
What many forecasters are beginning to pick up on is that for the past six months, Russian oil production growth has stagnated, even declining in four of those months. Is this situation a direct result of the lack of investment in
In a speech in 2004, Alexei Kontorovich, director of the Russian Institute of Oil and Gas Geology, estimated that it would take an investment of $14 billion to explore and develop oil deposits in
The proposed oil pipeline to export Siberian oil to
The latest negative forecast for
We remain haunted by an analytical observation about global oil production forecasts that points out that no country that has experienced three years of consecutive production declines has ever exceeded its prior production peak. This is not a comforting observation for energy forecasters counting on higher future Russian oil production to close the gap between global oil demand and supply.
The Return of El Niño?
Energy industries and markets are closely watching to see whether an El Niño weather pattern may be developing this summer. Should this pattern develop, there could be a huge shift in summer weather and tropical storm forecasts, significantly impacting natural gas demand, potential gas supply and pricing levels.
Weather forecasters are watching the development of Kelvin Waves in the
The weather models of the Bureau of Meteorology in
Our favorite weather forecaster, Accuweather Senior Meteorologist Joe Bastardi, made some interesting and enlightening observations about this debate about El Niño. He said, “I think there is a weak El Niño going on, but I believe we are getting carried away with El Niños and La Ninas nowadays. For instance, it’s like someone saying that there is the possibility of snow.” Bastardi said in the snow analogy, what is important is whether there is going to be a foot of snow or an inch of snow. To date, no one has quantified the El Niño impact.
Bastardi said he believes the weather forecasting community needs to be more cautious in its speculations about El Niño and La Nina. There are clearly a lot of big pulses up and down occurring, but at the moment cold water off of
Based on his assumption about the weather pattern in the South Pacific, Bastardi’s Atlantic hurricane forecast for this fall calls for five landfalling storms, one major hurricane and at least six shutdown days in the
Professor William Grey of the Atmospheric Department of the Colorado University has increased his hurricane forecast for 2005 to 13 named storms, seven hurricanes and three intense hurricanes, up from 11, six and three before. Grey’s forecast is based on the continued warming of the
With less than one month to go to the official start of the 2005 hurricane season, the development or moderation of the South Pacific conditions that might impact the development and strength of El Niño conditions will be important to watch. More discussion of these conditions will emerge as we approach June 1. For the time being, we suspect these hurricane forecasts will help support strong natural gas prices for the next 30 days, even with the current weakening of crude oil prices.
Bush Likes LNG, But Could We See a New OPEC?
At his press conference last Thursday night, President George W. Bush talked about the need for the
We recently attended a presentation about the successful corporate turnaround underway at
According to Foshee, the major limitation to the growth of LNG supply is the lack of liquefaction facilities. These facilities are extremely expensive costing in excess of $1 billion per unit (train). These export facilities also require the development of the gas supplies to feed them. As a result, it takes several years to build and bring into operation these gas export facilities. The construction time for gasification, or receiving, facilities is considerably shorter due to the lack of intellectual capital involved, since the gasification process merely involves warming up the super-cold liquefied gas.
Foshee does not believe that there will be many receiving terminals built on either the East or
The
The last significant reason why LNG will primarily come to the
The real development challenge for the LNG market is construction of adequate export capacity, especially as the global gas market shifts from a multitude of regional markets into a single global market. Besides gasification and liquefaction facilities, the industry needs more LNG ships. The shipbuilding industry is ramping up to construct a large number of new LNG tankers. The newest ships will be larger than their older siblings due to the need to improve the economics of transporting LNG. The cost of these ships is escalating with new vessels costing in the range of $170 million or more. Raising the capital for these vessels is becoming a challenge that only the largest shipowners are capable of handling.
Currently, a subsidiary of TeeKay Shipping (TK-NYSE) is in the market to finance construction of an LNG tanker fleet in the form of a master limited partnership (MLP). Management is currently on a roadshow to sell units in the partnership. The ability of this entity venture to pay a stream of income generating a current yield on the investment in excess of that of alternative moderate-risk debt securities should insure a large demand for the issue. According to Marine Money, the deal is being priced at a valuation of 12 times the projected earnings before interest, taxes and depreciation (EBITDA), or gross cash flow. MLPs by law must pay out 90% of their cash flow and the individual recipient pays taxes on the income distribution. While this is an attractive way of raising low-cost capital, it merely highlights that the development of the LNG market will require billions of dollars of infrastructure investment. Both the time required to raise this capital and to deploy it in new infrastructure facilities suggests a forecast-risk to timing the development of the LNG market.
What could upset the LNG market outlook? Two things in our estimation. First is the potential for LNG to arrive in the
In the case of the first issue, low-cost LNG is a function of two factors, the cost of the facilities to liquefy, transport and gasify the fuel along with an appropriate profit on the investment, and the cost of the gas. So far, most of the new LNG supplies are based on projects designed to exploit stranded or flared gas, i.e., gas that has little or no economic value or may actually have a cost associated with it. In these situations, with the gas value being very low, realizing any economic value represents a significant profit. The project economics of these types of gas supplies may allow, the delivered cost of the LNG to be well below current domestic gas prices. Our belief is that this condition will not last for long. The recent decision by Qatar, the current hotspot for natural gas related projects, to halt all further projects, including a number that were in the development stage, signifies that the government wants to go slow until it fully understands the economic impact of the development/sale of its resources.
The second potential negative for the LNG market is the development of a gas cartel. Last week, there was a meeting of a little-known, four-year-old organization called the Gas Exporting Countries Forum. The organization met in
In order to become a successful cartel, you need price-fixing capability. That means you need market concentration. At the present time, the members of the forum account for 53% of the natural gas imported by the industrialized countries that make up the Organization for Economic Cooperation & Development (OECD). That compares with OPEC’s current share of oil imports into these states of 52%. The countries invited to the forum by the Trinidad hosts included:
Predicting the development of an OPEC for natural gas is difficult, but conditions are ripe for one to emerge. Demand for natural gas on a global basis is growing as its clean-fuel attributes increasingly are recognized. Major gas-supplying countries are beginning to max out their current production. Because historically most gas volumes moved through pipelines, the development of the LNG market with its heavy capital investment and transportation requirements, spot gas markets are slowly emerging. This means that price increases, or decreases, for vessel cargoes can impact the economics for all gas markets. This is where the real pricing power can emerge.
What all this means is that the ability of any country to find relatively cheap sources of energy supply for any extended period, short of convincing suppliers to enter into low-priced, long-term contracts, is limited. Higher cost LNG may ultimately help some of the more environmentally friendly energy supply sources achieve economic profitability sooner than they might otherwise. The bottom line is that energy will remain a higher cost economic input for the foreseeable future.
Bush Open Fibber’s Closet
On the old radio show, Fibber McGee and Molly, Fibber had a closet where he put everything he wanted to save or hide. On every show, for some reason Fibber had to open the closet and everything fell out with a loud roar and to laughter from the audience. It almost looked liked President Bush was opening the country’s closet over the past two weeks. Last week, after his meeting with
Quite possibly the anti-environment President has embraced re-cycling – starting with abandoned military bases and offshore platforms. Gulf of
Saudi King Promises More Oil – Now and in the Future
When
Abdullah told President Bush that the Kingdom was prepared to invest $50 billion in its oil industry over the next five years, or double the investment of the past five years. That is welcome news for both the world and the oilfield service industry. However, this stepped up investment will only boost the Kingdom’s production to 13 million b/d by the end of the decade. Crown Prince Abdullah said that
Exhibit 1. 2010 OPEC Production Forecasts
Source: EIA 2004 Energy Outlook
This production increase is welcome, but he raises a question. When we look at the forecasts for future OPEC production in 2010, we find that this additional supply represents almost all the incremental oil already anticipated by forecasters sampled for the Energy Information Administration 2004 Long-term Outlook. Should we be encouraged or worried by the Saudi announcement of plans for production capacity increases? If a major expansion of Saudi’s output was not assumed by the forecasters then maybe we have more supply than anticipated. On the other hand, if a Saudi production expansion was assumed, then maybe we should be concerned because of the cost and time needed, given that almost all these long-term forecasts tend to slip in their realization.
Exhibit 2.
Source: Yahoo.com
The United Arab Emirates (UAE) announced recently that it plans to increase its productive capacity from its current 2.5 million b/d to 3.2 million b/d. At the UAE’s current production rate, the emirates have no surplus capacity. In June 2004, the UAE brought ExxonMobil (XOM- NYSE) in as a strategic partner in the development of the
In the mean time, the UAE has various projects designed to boost production to 3 million b/d by the end of 2006. The projects, all for onshore fields, are outlined in Exhibit 3.
Exhibit 3. UAE Oil Production Growth Projects
The UAE is made up four states. Those include
The Petroleum Challenge of Demographic Trends
One of the most insightful columns we have read recently about the impact of long-term demographic trends in
The reasons for this population decline are numerous. A primary one is the crisis in the Russian family and its impact on the decline in fertility rates. According to Russian government statistics, between 1981 and 2001, marriage rates have fallen by a third and divorce rates climbed by a third. The American Enterprise Institute’s Nicholas Eberstadt pointed out in an article in The Public Interest;
Russian fertility rates also plummeted during the breakup of the
The major reason for the projected decline in the Russian population is the sharp rise in death rates. In the past three decades, Russian mortality rates have risen by 40%. As a result, Russians are dying younger. In fact, Russians are now less healthy than their grandparents were in 1960. Russian life expectancies now approximate those in
Brooks’ interpretation of these statistics is that they reflect a country enduring a slow-motion version of the medieval Black Death. What he marvels at is that
Brooks believes that repair of the social fabric takes longer to recover. As a result, you can wind up with a country with a high economic growth rate and lingering military power that mask social chaos. We would agree, but extend the analysis further. In
Brooks carries his Russian analysis further to suggest that some of these social problems are what is deeply entrenched in the
“On the surface,
Brooks believes
Exhibit 4. China’s Economic Growth Record
Source: BHPBilliton
Despite the economic challenges facing the country, we expect
Contact PPHB:
1900 St. James Place, Suite 125
Houston, Texas 77056
Main Tel: (713) 621-8100
Main Fax: (713) 621-8166
www.pphb.com
Parks Paton Hoepfl & Brown is an independent investment banking firm providing financial advisory services, including merger and acquisition and capital raising assistance, exclusively to clients in the energy service industry.